Celestial Arches Collection Arrives Soon ✦ Join the Skolland Guild for First Dibs & Sneak Peeks ✦

As someone with a strong conviction for self-expression, I've always been fascinated by the versatility and beauty of jewelry. Jewelry, from necklaces to bracelets, earrings, and rings, has the power to tell a story when you choose a piece that reflects your individuality. However, the numerous options for selecting the right metal to match your style can be overwhelming. Two metals that have stood the test of time as popular choices are silver and gold. In this ultimate guide, I will explore the pros and cons of each metal to help you determine which is best suited for you.

An brief introduction to the Battle of the Metals

Throughout history, silver and gold have reigned supreme in the world of jewelry, their allure and prestige standing the test of time. These two metals possess distinctive qualities that have captured the hearts of people around the globe, making them highly sought-after options for a myriad of occasions. Whether you're drawn to the radiant warmth of gold or the sleek sophistication of silver, the debate between the two is not about one being superior to the other. Rather, it's about exploring the nuances of each metal and selecting the one that works with your unique fashion sense and lifestyle.

Understanding the differences between silver and gold

Silver and gold are both precious metals that occur naturally in stone & the earth's crust. However, they have different chemical and physical properties. Both Gold and Silver are soft and malleable metals that are resistant to tarnish and corrosion in their natural state and retain significant value over time. In its pure state, gold is often referred to as “24k” & pure silver is often referred to as 999 silver. 24K gold has a bright yellow color that is associated with wealth and luxury. On the other hand, pure silver has a white color that is associated with elegance and sophistication.

Pros and cons of silver and gold

Are you struggling to decide which metal is the best option for your fashion style? Silver or gold? Let us explore the pros and cons of each to help you make an informed decision.

While gold is a timeless and valuable metal that holds its value over time, it comes with a hefty price tag of around $1,988 per troy ounce as of 4/27/23. Although it is hypoallergenic and typically safe for most people to wear, pure gold is too soft for jewelry making, making it vulnerable to damage. Fortunately, gold alloys mixed with zinc, copper, nickel, and silver can create a sturdy and durable material that is resistant to tarnishing. These alloys make gold more durable than most silver alloys, making it a popular choice for everyday wear.

 On the other hand, silver is a more affordable metal that is widely available. It is hypoallergenic for most, making it a good choice for folks with sensitive skin. Like gold, in its pure state, it is too soft for jewelry making, so it does need to be alloyed with other metals such as copper, zinc, or tin to make it strong enough to hold up to wear. However, common silver alloys such as traditional 925 tarnish easily and require regular maintenance to keep them looking their best. 925 sterling is also generally too soft to safely hold stones in prong settings. Other silver alloys (tru silver, Argentium, continuum & others) are also considered "sterling" but unlike traditional 925-they have different alloy formulations. A few different sterling alloys are discussed below.



Types of silver: Sterling Silver, Argentium, and Continuum alloys

When it comes to silver, there are many different alloys used in jewelry making. Each alloy formulation has different working, color, tarnish resistance, and durability characteristics. In this article, we're covering 3 popular silver alloys: Sterling Silver, Argentium & Continuum.

Sterling silver is one of the most common silver alloys used in jewelry. It is made up of 92.5% silver and 7.5% other metals, such as copper, or zinc to make it strong enough for jewelry making. Although strong enough for jewelry making, most jewelers agree that it is too soft to safely hold stones in prong settings.

Argentium is a newer patented type of silver that is more tarnish-resistant than sterling silver. It is also hypoallergenic, has a brighter white color, and is stronger than traditional sterling.

Continuum is a patented type of silver that contains palladium, making it significantly more durable and scratch-resistant than sterling silver. It is also more expensive than Argentium or traditional sterling. Due to its increased durability, Continuum is a great white gold alternative for engagement or wedding rings.

Types of gold: 10k, 14k, and 18k

Gold comes in various purities, measured in karats (k). In the US, the most common purities are 10k, 14k, and 18k.

10k gold contains 41.7% gold and is the most durable and affordable type of gold.

14k gold contains 58.3% gold and is the most popular type of gold used in jewelry. It has a good balance of value and durability.

18k gold contains 75% gold and will is considered the most "luxurious". 18k yellow has a richer yellow color than 10k or 14K and is more expensive than 10k and 14k gold, the one caveat of this alloy is that it is softer than both 14K & 10K.

Rose, white & yellow gold are all available in 10K,14K & 18K options although the color does vary from karat to karat.

Matching metal to skin tone

When choosing the right metal for your style, it is essential to consider your skin tone. People with warm skin tones typically look best in gold, while people with cool skin tones look best in silver. If you have a neutral skin tone, you can wear both metals. You can determine your skin tone by looking at the veins on your wrist. If your veins appear green, you have a warm skin tone, and if they appear blue, you have a cool skin tone.
Gold vs silver engagement rings

Gold vs silver engagement rings

When it comes to engagement rings, both gold, and silver are popular choices. However, gold is the traditional choice for engagement rings, and it is associated with love, commitment, and eternity. Gold engagement rings come in various colors, including yellow, white, and rose gold. Silver engagement rings are a more modern choice and are associated with elegance and simplicity. While they are also more affordable than gold engagement rings, it is important to note that unless they are made with stronger alloys like Continuum, they will likely not last as long as gold engagement rings due to the reduced hardness. If you purchase a silver engagement ring, you should assume that repairs or a replacement will be needed in the future.

Caring for silver and gold jewelry

To keep your silver and gold jewelry looking its best, you need to care for it properly. Silver jewelry should be stored in an airtight container to prevent tarnishing. Both Gold & Silver jewelry can be cleaned with a soft cloth and mild soap, non-abrasive soap, and water. (Such as Dawn/ Mrs. Meyers). Polishing cloths can also be used. Avoid using harsh chemicals or abrasive materials that can scratch the metal. Always make sure to remove your jewelry when swimming in chlorinated pools, and when cleaning with chemicals around your home.

Conclusion: choosing the right metal for your story

Choosing the right metal for you is a personal decision that depends on your taste, budget, and lifestyle. Whether you prefer the warm glow of gold or the cool sheen of silver, both metals have unique properties that make them popular choices for various occasions. By understanding the differences between silver and gold, considering your skin tone, and caring for your jewelry properly, you can discover the right metal for your style and enjoy your jewelry for years to come.


 Ready to find your perfect piece? Shop silver & gold pieces.